New York New York Pizza

3757 Bruce B Downs Blvd, Wesley Chapel, FL 33544, USA

About New York New York Pizza

4.3 / 5

from reviews

Is this your business?

    Lady Jay
    -
    January 18, 2025

    Ordered for the first time recently and was pleased with one part of my food and not so much with the other. I'll say that if you're very particular about gloves being used you don't want to try this place because they don't. I wasn't aware of this as I called in my order for pick up. Had I known this, I would not have chosen this restaurant. The pizza slice was absolutely delicious although it is the most that I've ever paid for only a slice. It had a crispy bottom which I hadn't experienced before from other places unless you ask for it to be crispy. Having a pizza slice that can be picked up and doesn't flop on you is so satisfying and I was very pleased. That alone was worth me trying them and made me happy. The garlic knots though I didn't enjoy but perhaps maybe fresh cut garlic placed on top of the bread is your jam. It is not mine and I wouldn't recommend them. The marinara was more liquidy than chunky which again isn't my preference but maybe other folks like it that way. Overall it was a decent experience, the employee that answered the phone to take my order was the same person at the counter when I arrived and she was very pleasant and friendly.

    B.Scarlett
    -
    December 15, 2024

    We got the veggie pizza with garlic and olive oil sauce and fried mushrooms. The pizza was absolutely delicious! Looking forward to trying other things in their menu. Lots of options for vegetarians! Service was great and the place looks clean and welcoming.

    Christopher Williams
    -
    May 29, 2025

    Ordered the extra large thin crust bbq chicken I don’t think there was any chicken on it maybe the faintest of possibly thinly shaved deli chicken. The pizza crust was fine unfortunately no or the littlest amount of chicken. Not going to order from here again.

    Bri Annah
    -
    May 31, 2025

    I’ve been coming to you guys for a while, but last night was special because the meat lovers pizza I ordered was apart of my baby’s last meals this weekend and she absolutely loved it 🥰

    Tiffani Amber Melendez
    -
    November 14, 2024

    The service on the phone and the delivery was great. I didn’t have a problem with ordering, and the delivery driver was kind. However, I ordered two separate orders. The first one was well, pizza is great. The wings for the second separate order though was unsatisfactory to me. As a server in the industry for 7 years, I don’t expect wings to be sitting and saturating in the sauce in the to-go container, let alone not tossed in the sauce itself. Tenders, are tenders based off inventory selection, and do wish they were a better quality product but I understand. The wings tossed in these sauces and the box just full of sauce sitting in the parchment paper in the box was unappetizing unfortunately. It still however is a great business and the pizza truly is delicious, the wings and tenders just didn’t not meet satisfaction.

    New York New York Pizza

    Our Address

    3757 Bruce B Downs Blvd, Wesley Chapel, FL 33544, USA

    Let C&S Local Marketing Increase Your Restaurant’s Visibility and Exposure on the Internet!

    Read More

    Is YOUR Restaurant Listed in Our Directory?

    ==> ==> List YOUR Restaurant in Our Directory!<== <==

    Basic Listings are FREE!