Best NY Pizza of Wesley Chapel

27429 Wesley Chapel Blvd, Wesley Chapel, FL 33544, USA

About Best NY Pizza of Wesley Chapel

4.2 / 5

from reviews

Is this your business?

    Lauren Baggio
    -
    April 07, 2024

    A customer of mine ordered a pizza that was the best thing I've ever had from NY Best Pizza and when I tried to reorder it last night, I felt absolutely taken advantage of ! Apparently this pizza is called "grandma's sicilian" well, I ordered "grandma's style" joseph even went through all the ingredients (as I'm waiting on the other line at work, in the bar) light cheese, light marinara, basil pesto, etc. I'm assuming he was making sure the kitchen could make it. I've worked in restaurants my whole adult life, I understand the ins and outs of a restaurant, the issue I had is that I paid $51 for that pizza and 20 boneless wings. Boneless wings were $18 (plus the extra charge for two dipping sauces that were different sizes, 4 oz & 2 oz, & the boneless did not come with dipping sauce). Thinking I was going to get a sicilian, grandma's sicilian, I was absolutely shocked when I saw that we received a circular pie with only 8 slices and it was thinner than their normal pizzas. I called them back immediately (40 min after placing our order) and was placed on hold, I guess it makes sense because it was 15 min til closing and they probably weren't taking new orders. If I wasn't busy at work and if NY pizza wasn't closing, I would've walked down to complain. My coworkers and I paid $30 for this pizza that was delicious, but not a sicilian. We would've gotten 15 plus pieces with the sicilian and we only received 8. I guess I was hoping for what my customer received and didn't realize I needed to explicitly say sicilian, even though the only style of the "grandma's pizza" was sicilian. I will let my customers buy food from them, but I will never spend my money there again, nor will I recommend my customers to go there. They close early anyway (10pm) and they don't walk the pizzas down the plaza, whereas other pizza places around us are open til 12 and will deliver it. I might as well save money going elsewhere to ensure I get what I order and have no surprises.

    Ted Mcghie
    -
    April 07, 2024

    First, the price doesn't match the online price. Second, which should be first. I asked for no green peppers or black olives. Thirdly, it's says NY Pizza because it's thin sliced. Don't be fooled. It doesn't taste like any pizza I've ever gotten from NY. The only reason I gave them 2 stars is because the person at the register was funny. He told me that this was a gourmet pizza, the kind you would get if you sat down at a restaurant. If you wanted cheap pizza, you could've gone to Domino's. As he waved his hands in the air like that air blow-up thing that you see in front of businesses. He said, "Have a good night." I thought that was hilarious. Normally, I would've told them to make another pizza, but that would mean waiting for another 15 min. My nephew had to remove the green peppers off of his slices.

    Lourin King
    -
    September 01, 2024

    I have Ordered twice via Door Dash and this last order My husband picked up. I can't thank this establishment enough for the Consistency!!! Love the red pizza and the White pizza. Toppings are generous....except the fresh basil, I think should have been MUCH more. None the less I will continue to order. Great, Great NY Pizza. Photos next time

    Dwight Spivey
    -
    July 21, 2024

    To be honest the pizza looked good. Unfortunately the taste was not. Way too much red sauce. The bread/dough tastes like something I can’t explain. The more I ate the worse it tasted. I ordered a small. Asked for thin crust. That didn’t happen. I couldn’t eat half of it before I was ripping the toppings off the top of it. But the sauce was way too much for me to eat any more. This is just my opinion. I’m sure some people love it. I’ll stick with Fl. Pizza. The New Yorkers can have this. 🤮🙄

    Jason Ballard
    -
    July 16, 2023

    YUM!! Super friendly staff and good tasting food. Pizza with 1 topping & garlic parm boneless wings + 1 drink was $42 ish. Pizza was good. Our son liked the parm boneless wings but thought they were a tad too garlicky. Inside is decorated awesome! Bathrooms are nice and clean! A+ decor. We would recommend the spot and suggest that you try it and leave it raining to help other people. We have visited more than once.

    Best NY Pizza of Wesley Chapel

    Our Address

    27429 Wesley Chapel Blvd, Wesley Chapel, FL 33544, USA

    Ad 2

    Let C&S Local Marketing Increase Your Restaurant’s Visibility and Exposure on the Internet!

    Read More

    Ads Title

    Is YOUR Restaurant Listed in Our Directory?

    ==> ==> List YOUR Restaurant in Our Directory!<== <==

    Basic Listings are FREE!