My girlfriend and I ordered a supreme pizza for delivery on a Saturday evening. When it arrived it was super thin and soggy. The toppings weren't distribute around the pizza, just a big pile in the middle. Called and asked for a new one and the lady on the phone told me to piss off. I expected this pizza to be great because it was close to $30. First and last time eating here
Jessica Howry
-
August 13, 2025
Great food, but don’t come in hungry an hour before close. you’ll be let down when they turn you away. We showed up as a party of 5 at 8pm on a Tuesday and were told they couldn’t serve us because they began closing (an hour before posted store hours). Usually love it here, but was honestly shocked when we were told they wouldn’t be serving us this evening. I recommend updating your store hours to reflect when your kitchen closes, rather than your dining room. We never intended to be an imposition, but now that we know, probably won’t be returning anytime soon.
Jan Hitchko
-
July 27, 2025
We frequent this Joey’s and we are usually greeted by Austin. He is quick to help us and get us seated. If the server is busy he helps out with our drinks and clears our dishes. He is a very hard worker and is always nice and friendly! You are lucky to have him there!
Ty O
-
May 26, 2024
The wings were barely cooked and covered in what’s supposed to be garlic pram sauce which was extremely watery. I ended up having to pop them in my air fryer to recook them. The pizza look decent until you eat it. Crust was brick hard and nothing like New York style pizza, they should remove New York from their Name. Garlic knots literally taste like nothing I wasted my $34 and won’t be returning.
Mike T
-
August 09, 2024
Joey's Pizza never disappoints! Their pizza is hands down one of the best I've ever had—perfectly crispy crust, flavorful sauce, and just the right amount of toppings. The antipasto salad is a must-try, fresh and loaded with delicious ingredients that complement the meal perfectly. And let's not forget the garlic knots; they are simply divine, buttery, and full of flavor. Every visit to Joey's is a treat. Highly recommend!
Our Address
1312 Seven Springs Blvd, New Port Richey, FL 34655, USA
My girlfriend and I ordered a supreme pizza for delivery on a Saturday evening. When it arrived it was super thin and soggy. The toppings weren't distribute around the pizza, just a big pile in the middle. Called and asked for a new one and the lady on the phone told me to piss off. I expected this pizza to be great because it was close to $30. First and last time eating here
Great food, but don’t come in hungry an hour before close. you’ll be let down when they turn you away. We showed up as a party of 5 at 8pm on a Tuesday and were told they couldn’t serve us because they began closing (an hour before posted store hours). Usually love it here, but was honestly shocked when we were told they wouldn’t be serving us this evening. I recommend updating your store hours to reflect when your kitchen closes, rather than your dining room. We never intended to be an imposition, but now that we know, probably won’t be returning anytime soon.
We frequent this Joey’s and we are usually greeted by Austin. He is quick to help us and get us seated. If the server is busy he helps out with our drinks and clears our dishes. He is a very hard worker and is always nice and friendly! You are lucky to have him there!
The wings were barely cooked and covered in what’s supposed to be garlic pram sauce which was extremely watery. I ended up having to pop them in my air fryer to recook them. The pizza look decent until you eat it. Crust was brick hard and nothing like New York style pizza, they should remove New York from their Name. Garlic knots literally taste like nothing I wasted my $34 and won’t be returning.
Joey's Pizza never disappoints! Their pizza is hands down one of the best I've ever had—perfectly crispy crust, flavorful sauce, and just the right amount of toppings. The antipasto salad is a must-try, fresh and loaded with delicious ingredients that complement the meal perfectly. And let's not forget the garlic knots; they are simply divine, buttery, and full of flavor. Every visit to Joey's is a treat. Highly recommend!