The best pizza place in Wesley Chapel! The white pizza is some of the best we’ve had anywhere. Delicious regular cheese and pepperoni pizza. Great calzones and garlic knots! Most importantly: CONSISTENT! It’s our weekly stop for months and nails the NY/NJ flavor.
Buz Massengale
-
August 16, 2025
This was our first take out pizza order, and the only descriptions that apply are superlatives. Ordering online was seamless, and the order was ready even before I could drive up to pick it up. It far exceeded the quality of pizza that can be found at any chain store. The ingredients were all fresh and in sufficient quantity. The pie was cooked to perfection with a perfect crust crispness and flavorful throughout. It was hot on delivery and well packaged. We will definitely be making more orders in the future.
Amy Jackson-Yancy
-
April 30, 2025
Update: its been 6 years since i last reviewed Pizza Mania. So I figured I'd update. Still really good pizza, really good customer service and a really good deal for the food you get. Love the meat lovers pizza. Everything I've ate has been really good.
This is my go to pizza place when I'm in new Tampa/Wesley Chapel area....everything I've ever ordered has been great...I've been here when they first open in the morning 11 am, mid afternoon and evening....staff is always friendly....clean dining area, clean food prep area and clean restroom....parking is kinda crazy...they have seven spaces on side of building next to door but 3 spaces are 10 minute only for pick up, but plenty of parking further away in main parking lot. Their entry door is on the side. Never really had any problems with this place. Except once when we went with a bigger group (10 people in our party) there was a mix up on our order and it took a while to receive our order but they gave us free garlic knots. Waitresses are always fast and friendly. Always on top of your needs.
Michael Cacioppo
-
July 08, 2025
The best pizza place outside of NJ, and DEFINITELY in all of Florida. I've been coming here for 20 years and the food and service has been top notch the whole time!
I even had them cater my wedding in 2014 and everyone loved the food.
Johnny knows what he is doing and is an all around great guy.
Not only is their Pizza the best, but good luck finding better cannolis anywhere else in Tampa!
I'm so glad to be able to get a taste of home (NJ) right here in Wesley Chapel.
Orion Outerbridge
-
August 31, 2025
Best pizza in Wesley Chapel by far!! Owner is also an amazing person. He once called me when I forgot to pick up my pizza, after the restaurant closed. He waited until I got there and was very understanding of my mishap. Most places wouldn't have bothered to call. You can't beat great people, service, and pizza!!!
Our Address
1734 Bruce B Downs Blvd, Wesley Chapel, FL 33544, USA
The best pizza place in Wesley Chapel! The white pizza is some of the best we’ve had anywhere. Delicious regular cheese and pepperoni pizza. Great calzones and garlic knots! Most importantly: CONSISTENT! It’s our weekly stop for months and nails the NY/NJ flavor.
This was our first take out pizza order, and the only descriptions that apply are superlatives. Ordering online was seamless, and the order was ready even before I could drive up to pick it up. It far exceeded the quality of pizza that can be found at any chain store. The ingredients were all fresh and in sufficient quantity. The pie was cooked to perfection with a perfect crust crispness and flavorful throughout. It was hot on delivery and well packaged. We will definitely be making more orders in the future.
Update: its been 6 years since i last reviewed Pizza Mania. So I figured I'd update. Still really good pizza, really good customer service and a really good deal for the food you get. Love the meat lovers pizza. Everything I've ate has been really good. This is my go to pizza place when I'm in new Tampa/Wesley Chapel area....everything I've ever ordered has been great...I've been here when they first open in the morning 11 am, mid afternoon and evening....staff is always friendly....clean dining area, clean food prep area and clean restroom....parking is kinda crazy...they have seven spaces on side of building next to door but 3 spaces are 10 minute only for pick up, but plenty of parking further away in main parking lot. Their entry door is on the side. Never really had any problems with this place. Except once when we went with a bigger group (10 people in our party) there was a mix up on our order and it took a while to receive our order but they gave us free garlic knots. Waitresses are always fast and friendly. Always on top of your needs.
The best pizza place outside of NJ, and DEFINITELY in all of Florida. I've been coming here for 20 years and the food and service has been top notch the whole time! I even had them cater my wedding in 2014 and everyone loved the food. Johnny knows what he is doing and is an all around great guy. Not only is their Pizza the best, but good luck finding better cannolis anywhere else in Tampa! I'm so glad to be able to get a taste of home (NJ) right here in Wesley Chapel.
Best pizza in Wesley Chapel by far!! Owner is also an amazing person. He once called me when I forgot to pick up my pizza, after the restaurant closed. He waited until I got there and was very understanding of my mishap. Most places wouldn't have bothered to call. You can't beat great people, service, and pizza!!!