Our family loves pizza suprema! Such a staple for our household. Our go to is half agrigento and half pepperoni (for our 3 year old lol) and man, they make the pizza perfect every single time! We tried the bruschetta for the first time tonight and omg!!!! 20/10. Life long customers here!! If you aren't ordering your pizza from pizza suprema, what are you doing?!?!!
Nicole
-
August 25, 2025
I found this place on lunch break a few months back and I’ve been back frequently ever since. I’ve tried several pizza places in this area and this is by far the best tasting, and luckily also really affordable. The dough always tastes fresh and the pizza sauce is just right in flavor. The people who work here have always been super nice as well. Definitely recommend!
Darnell Eason
-
April 29, 2025
Absolutely five stars. The food at Pizza Suprema was delicious and fresh. Since moving down to Tampa from New York, this is the closest thing to real New York pizza that we have found. The staff was also fantastic. My son was wearing his Spider-Man watch and shirt, and they went out of their way to acknowledge him and make him feel like a million bucks. It made his day and ours. Great food, great service, and a place we will definitely keep coming back to.
Teri Mullis
-
July 25, 2025
First time customer was referred by a friend A little hole in the wall pizzeria, blown away by the service hands down they treat you like family. Pizza was amazing exactly what I expected so good! Definitely will be a returning customer for sure!
Soraya Vicini
-
April 04, 2025
Bring friends & family & co Workers here🍕
Slate bottom crunchy flavorful pizzas…authentic Brooklyn❤️
Drop in/Call ahead/Order out/etc… Homemade CHEESECAKE to go🛎️Specials Amazing customer service…momma taught em well!
Our family loves pizza suprema! Such a staple for our household. Our go to is half agrigento and half pepperoni (for our 3 year old lol) and man, they make the pizza perfect every single time! We tried the bruschetta for the first time tonight and omg!!!! 20/10. Life long customers here!! If you aren't ordering your pizza from pizza suprema, what are you doing?!?!!
I found this place on lunch break a few months back and I’ve been back frequently ever since. I’ve tried several pizza places in this area and this is by far the best tasting, and luckily also really affordable. The dough always tastes fresh and the pizza sauce is just right in flavor. The people who work here have always been super nice as well. Definitely recommend!
Absolutely five stars. The food at Pizza Suprema was delicious and fresh. Since moving down to Tampa from New York, this is the closest thing to real New York pizza that we have found. The staff was also fantastic. My son was wearing his Spider-Man watch and shirt, and they went out of their way to acknowledge him and make him feel like a million bucks. It made his day and ours. Great food, great service, and a place we will definitely keep coming back to.
First time customer was referred by a friend A little hole in the wall pizzeria, blown away by the service hands down they treat you like family. Pizza was amazing exactly what I expected so good! Definitely will be a returning customer for sure!
Bring friends & family & co Workers here🍕 Slate bottom crunchy flavorful pizzas…authentic Brooklyn❤️ Drop in/Call ahead/Order out/etc… Homemade CHEESECAKE to go🛎️Specials Amazing customer service…momma taught em well!