I’ve lived in the Land O Lakes area For 23 years. This is the best pizza and Caesar salad EVER! The taste of the sauce is incredible and how they know the right amount of sauce, chef’s kiss, the taste of the cheese, and the bake of the pizza is more than five stars! It brought me back to Italy! The Caesar dressing, it is the best tasting dressing I’ve had in years! My daughter agrees! 💯 🇮🇹
Darnell Eason
-
April 29, 2025
Absolutely five stars. The food at Pizza Suprema was delicious and fresh. Since moving down to Tampa from New York, this is the closest thing to real New York pizza that we have found. The staff was also fantastic. My son was wearing his Spider-Man watch and shirt, and they went out of their way to acknowledge him and make him feel like a million bucks. It made his day and ours. Great food, great service, and a place we will definitely keep coming back to.
Soraya Vicini
-
April 04, 2025
Bring friends & family & co Workers here🍕
Slate bottom crunchy flavorful pizzas…authentic Brooklyn❤️
Drop in/Call ahead/Order out/etc… Homemade CHEESECAKE to go🛎️Specials Amazing customer service…momma taught em well!
Peter Mestre
-
June 03, 2025
Hands down one of the best Pizza Joints in the Tampa Bay Area. They make the sauce daily and use good quality ingredients, the owner Anthony is a great and friendly guy! I’ve been coming here for years and don’t plan on changing that.
Kassi Cusumano
-
May 11, 2024
Delicious!! We drove almost an hour to visit after reading other reviews and it did not disappoint!! Pizza was authentic and reminded me of back home in NY. Garlic knots were just okay. Dense and lacking flavor. The dining room had 5 or so tables, so it doesn’t have a restaurant feel if that’s what you’re looking for. But if you’re in the area, or an hour away and are looking for outstanding pizza, this is the place!!
I’ve lived in the Land O Lakes area For 23 years. This is the best pizza and Caesar salad EVER! The taste of the sauce is incredible and how they know the right amount of sauce, chef’s kiss, the taste of the cheese, and the bake of the pizza is more than five stars! It brought me back to Italy! The Caesar dressing, it is the best tasting dressing I’ve had in years! My daughter agrees! 💯 🇮🇹
Absolutely five stars. The food at Pizza Suprema was delicious and fresh. Since moving down to Tampa from New York, this is the closest thing to real New York pizza that we have found. The staff was also fantastic. My son was wearing his Spider-Man watch and shirt, and they went out of their way to acknowledge him and make him feel like a million bucks. It made his day and ours. Great food, great service, and a place we will definitely keep coming back to.
Bring friends & family & co Workers here🍕 Slate bottom crunchy flavorful pizzas…authentic Brooklyn❤️ Drop in/Call ahead/Order out/etc… Homemade CHEESECAKE to go🛎️Specials Amazing customer service…momma taught em well!
Hands down one of the best Pizza Joints in the Tampa Bay Area. They make the sauce daily and use good quality ingredients, the owner Anthony is a great and friendly guy! I’ve been coming here for years and don’t plan on changing that.
Delicious!! We drove almost an hour to visit after reading other reviews and it did not disappoint!! Pizza was authentic and reminded me of back home in NY. Garlic knots were just okay. Dense and lacking flavor. The dining room had 5 or so tables, so it doesn’t have a restaurant feel if that’s what you’re looking for. But if you’re in the area, or an hour away and are looking for outstanding pizza, this is the place!!