This place is the REAL deal! My parents owned a pizzeria in Jersey & my dad was from Naples like the owners. Hearing their accents reminded me so much of my dad❤️. When I tell you the food was great & the owners were AWESOME... it was & they were!
I've been craving Sicilian pizza with real Italian sausage (most places in Florida use sausage crumble) & this did not disappoint! The chicken parmigiana sandwich was the best I ever had, the pizza was DELICIOUS,
the arancini's were soooo good & the sauce.... 🤌🏻 IYKYK!!! It was so good I ate 1 of the dipping cups with a spoon 🤣
If you're missing pizza & Italian food from back home, stop in. You won't regret it!
Yes, you can buy both regular & Sicilian pies by the slice.
Marty
-
March 17, 2026
10/10 Absolutely Amazing Pizza.....
Super delicious,this NJ style pie, islight and airy, yet the crispy crust was perfect. Great flavor from all the amazing quality ingredients. They definitely know what they are doing here. Absolutely must try destination.
Instagram/TikTok @foodieadventuresusa
Paul Young
-
March 07, 2026
I used to really like The Pizza Pie as it was the closest thing I could find in town to “real” pizza. I heard the location is under new ownership from our neighborhood facebook group. I wanted to try it again to see if the quality was still solid. Several people in the group commented how new ownership had raised prices to ridiculous levels, but I certainly wasn’t prepared for just how much.
I ordered a large white pizza and added mushrooms, spinach, and garlic to half of it. The total came to $40.00. And this wasn’t for delivery so there was no delivery fees and ordered directly from the location. When you place an order there is even a thank you that says “thanks for ordering directly from us. Other services charge an additional 30%, and this allows us to keep our prices reasonable.” Lol at “reasonable.”
When a restaurant charges $3.55 EACH to add spinach, mushrooms, and garlic to a whole pie you expect a decent amount ($1.76 to a half pie). What I got was a pizza pretty lacking in mushrooms. It’s also crazy that the $3.55 price for a topping is the same whether you want sausage or banana peppers.
As far as the food quality, it’s pretty tasty. But at a price point of $40.00, it should blow me away and it just didn’t.
Christina Brooks
-
May 10, 2026
We ordered takeout from The Pizza Pie today after seeing them on TikTok and got the 14-inch meat lovers pizza, wings, and garlic knots. The pizza was good, but nothing especially memorable. The wings had decent flavor, but by the time we got home they were very soggy. Better packaging that allows steam to escape or absorbs moisture would help keep them crispy for takeout orders.
Unfortunately, the garlic knots were the biggest disappointment. They were extremely tiny. I even took a picture with a quarter for scale because they were the smallest garlic knots we’ve ever seen. More importantly, they tasted stale, like they had been sitting out all day or longer. They were hard, dry, and tough to eat.
To make matters worse, when I got to my car I realized the garlic knot bag had completely soaked through and broken. I brought it back inside, and there was no apology or acknowledgment of the inconvenience. They simply put the same cold garlic knots into a new bag with a fresh container of sauce and sent me back out.
It’s also worth mentioning that ordering online through their website was considerably more expensive than calling the order in directly. The pricing difference was noticeable enough to be disappointing, especially on top of the added credit/debit card processing fee unless you pay cash.
Overall, spending $39 and change for a medium pizza, wings, and tiny garlic knots felt overpriced for the quality and service we received.
Bernie
-
February 27, 2026
We had the opportunity to try several items on our visit to this location. The appetizer was soo good with items you usually don't see like artichoke hearts and panecetta. The chicken parmesan was a very good portion and their sauce paired perfectly with it. Pizza dough and sauce was just as accomodating and I would definitely order on a regular basis. This restaurant is out to please and are energetic and resourceful on offering smaller tidbits like the amazing garlic knots and dessert. So east to just add it to your order. Overall, this is the place for a fabulous take out and to enjoy excellent food.
Our Address
6464 Land O' Lakes Blvd, Land O' Lakes, FL 34638, USA
This place is the REAL deal! My parents owned a pizzeria in Jersey & my dad was from Naples like the owners. Hearing their accents reminded me so much of my dad❤️. When I tell you the food was great & the owners were AWESOME... it was & they were! I've been craving Sicilian pizza with real Italian sausage (most places in Florida use sausage crumble) & this did not disappoint! The chicken parmigiana sandwich was the best I ever had, the pizza was DELICIOUS, the arancini's were soooo good & the sauce.... 🤌🏻 IYKYK!!! It was so good I ate 1 of the dipping cups with a spoon 🤣 If you're missing pizza & Italian food from back home, stop in. You won't regret it! Yes, you can buy both regular & Sicilian pies by the slice.
10/10 Absolutely Amazing Pizza..... Super delicious,this NJ style pie, islight and airy, yet the crispy crust was perfect. Great flavor from all the amazing quality ingredients. They definitely know what they are doing here. Absolutely must try destination. Instagram/TikTok @foodieadventuresusa
I used to really like The Pizza Pie as it was the closest thing I could find in town to “real” pizza. I heard the location is under new ownership from our neighborhood facebook group. I wanted to try it again to see if the quality was still solid. Several people in the group commented how new ownership had raised prices to ridiculous levels, but I certainly wasn’t prepared for just how much. I ordered a large white pizza and added mushrooms, spinach, and garlic to half of it. The total came to $40.00. And this wasn’t for delivery so there was no delivery fees and ordered directly from the location. When you place an order there is even a thank you that says “thanks for ordering directly from us. Other services charge an additional 30%, and this allows us to keep our prices reasonable.” Lol at “reasonable.” When a restaurant charges $3.55 EACH to add spinach, mushrooms, and garlic to a whole pie you expect a decent amount ($1.76 to a half pie). What I got was a pizza pretty lacking in mushrooms. It’s also crazy that the $3.55 price for a topping is the same whether you want sausage or banana peppers. As far as the food quality, it’s pretty tasty. But at a price point of $40.00, it should blow me away and it just didn’t.
We ordered takeout from The Pizza Pie today after seeing them on TikTok and got the 14-inch meat lovers pizza, wings, and garlic knots. The pizza was good, but nothing especially memorable. The wings had decent flavor, but by the time we got home they were very soggy. Better packaging that allows steam to escape or absorbs moisture would help keep them crispy for takeout orders. Unfortunately, the garlic knots were the biggest disappointment. They were extremely tiny. I even took a picture with a quarter for scale because they were the smallest garlic knots we’ve ever seen. More importantly, they tasted stale, like they had been sitting out all day or longer. They were hard, dry, and tough to eat. To make matters worse, when I got to my car I realized the garlic knot bag had completely soaked through and broken. I brought it back inside, and there was no apology or acknowledgment of the inconvenience. They simply put the same cold garlic knots into a new bag with a fresh container of sauce and sent me back out. It’s also worth mentioning that ordering online through their website was considerably more expensive than calling the order in directly. The pricing difference was noticeable enough to be disappointing, especially on top of the added credit/debit card processing fee unless you pay cash. Overall, spending $39 and change for a medium pizza, wings, and tiny garlic knots felt overpriced for the quality and service we received.
We had the opportunity to try several items on our visit to this location. The appetizer was soo good with items you usually don't see like artichoke hearts and panecetta. The chicken parmesan was a very good portion and their sauce paired perfectly with it. Pizza dough and sauce was just as accomodating and I would definitely order on a regular basis. This restaurant is out to please and are energetic and resourceful on offering smaller tidbits like the amazing garlic knots and dessert. So east to just add it to your order. Overall, this is the place for a fabulous take out and to enjoy excellent food.